TL09 View of School Libraries

TL09 View of School Libraries (Photo credit: Carol VanHook)

Many students  are reluctant readers. I’m not talking about students who are reluctant to read because they have reading disabilities. I’m talking about students who can read but just don’t like reading and try to avoid it whenever possible. There are many reasons students don’t like to read.  For example,

  • some families don’t value reading so students come to school thinking reading isn’t important;
  • some students think reading isn’t cool and discourage their friends from reading; and
  • some people think reading is a waste of time and people should go do something  instead of just sitting and reading.

I want to share an anecdote with you that helped remind me why some kids won’t read.  I can’t even imagine not reading. But, that’s me, and I have to remember that. I had a student in a grade 12 learning strategies class a few semesters ago who didn’t like reading.  I’ll call  him Kyle.  After I had introduced the daily reading activity, Kyle told me he didn’t like to read.  (What else is new, I thought.) He told me he had never read an entire book in the 13 years he’s been in school. Unfortunately, I’ve heard that said before too. Many of my students  are  reluctant readers, but I continue to encourage them to read anyway. I don’t give up because you just never know.

Reluctant readers often have difficulty finding books they would like to read. When Kyle couldn’t find a book  to read in the entire school library, I asked him what kinds of movies did he like watching. He told me, but I can’t remember just now but it doesn’t really matter . My point is  whatever type of movie he liked watching  is the type of book I would have suggest he read.  Suggesting students use the kind of movies they like to watch  to help them choose books they might find interesting to read is a good starting point for kids who can’t find a book. I figure students go to movies all the time so they feel  comfortable with movies , but books and libraries  are  probably a pretty scary for someone who doesn’t read much.  I appreciate that, so I usually help students find a book with the school librarian’s help. She’s a wonderful resource for reluctant readers.

By the end of the semester Kyle had read seven or eight books.  He told me he even read books on the bus.  Wow. I  was immediately impressed (ha!) with the fact that Kyle who was in grade 12 hadn’t finish reading a book before in all the time he was in school and in my class (ha!)  he had read seven books.  I had helped him become an avid reader.    I had made a difference (ha!) .  Kyle  had become an avid reader.  That was great. But Kyle didn’t think it was so great.  Kyle’s girl friend hated the fact he read all the time,  even on the bus. She told him he was turning into a geek and was losing his cool factor. She didn’t want him to be geeky. Personally, I think she was feeling ignored.  She had to compete with books for his attention and didn’t like it one bit. Kyle told me he wouldn’t be reading anymore books.  Seven books were enough. What?  Seven book were enough.  I didn’t know what to say to him. I was stunned.  Reading seven books in a life time was enough? Really! I hoped that wouldn’t be the case. I think he thought that books were for school and since he was done with school because he graduated, he was done with books. How was he able to get through school without reading a book?  He had marvelous coping skills I guess.

I think some students don’t like to read because they don’t get involved with what they are reading.  Let me explain.  When I’m reading something I get involved with the text and will talk to the text and say things such as

  • I don’t get it;
  • I get it now;
  • what does that word mean;
  • I can relate to that ;
  • I can’t read because there’s too much noise in the room;
  • I really like the character; and
  • etc.

When I’m talking to the text, I’m engaging with it and making the reading experience more meaningful to me.  I want my students to be engaged with the text they are reading to make it more meaningful for them. So I decided I would have them complete a reading log where they could talk to the text they were reading.  Reading logs usually include columns for dates and the pages read on that particular day.  My  talking to the text reading log includes columns for dates, for quotations from the text and page number, and for comments about the quotations.   Students had to read in order to make comments. It would be more difficult for them to cheat and  just fill in the date and page numbers they hadn’t actually read.

Students would read their books and while reading would  choose a  sentence or two that spoke to them in some way.  Then they would comment or talk about  how the sentence spoke to them. I told my students that when they were making comments they were really talking to the books. The idea of talking to books got their attention.  They thought I was weird, but that’s OK.  I got their attention.  I modeled what it meant to talk to books.  I told them I also talk to the TV and to movies.   I wanted them to have conversations with their books.   I would  provide sentence stems to help them to start to think about their reading.  I would read their comments  about the text they were reading and made thoughtful comments (I hope)  about their comments. Of course, I would give  students the option of sharing their comments with me and other students or keeping their comments private.  I can only remember one student who wanted his comments to remain private.  I think sharing our comments helped us develop a more positive relationship.  We got to now know another better.  I didn’t get the sense that students were writing what they thought I wanted to hear, but who knows.  At least they were reading and thinking about their reading.  What they wrote had to fit with the sentences they chose.

Oh yes, the students would always have to give a reason why they thought what they did about the sentence or sentences they had chosen. For example, if a students wrote that she could relate to the character, she would have to say how.  She just couldn’t say she related to April.  She’d have to say she related to April because she too had an annoying little sister who always wanted to do what she did.

Some semesters I would have students read  three days a week and some semesters I would have them read everyday.  If I got busy and forgot it was the day we were supposed to read, students  would remind me that   we supposed to read and complete the log. Most of my students liked talking to their books.  It’s not realistic to think that all students would like any given strategy.   Sometimes I’m more of an optimist than a realist, when it comes to trying new strategies to get students to do their best.  Fortunately, my students help me stay balanced.

If you’d like a copy of my sentence stems and the reading log I used, I’d be delighted to share them.  Just leave a request in the comment box below. You could use the resources as is or as a starting point to help develop your own handouts.



Enhanced by Zemanta

Enjoyed reading this post? Subscribe to Teachers at Risk.


10 Responses to “Improve students’ reading experiences by having them talk to the books they are reading in a reading log”

  1. Melanie on June 25th, 2012 5:44 pm

    I love this idea of talking to the text. I also love the story of Kyle. (Too bad his girlfriend was so anti-reading.) Please send me the sentence stems and reading log you use. We are going to Block Scheduling and I want to do more silent reading, but I want students to be accountable and enjoy it. Perhaps this will help! Thank you!
    Melanie´s last blog post ..Questioning Strategies that Promote Discussion

  2. Pam Darden on June 25th, 2012 8:25 pm

    I’ve had my students write a “Somebody wanted…but……….” summary for their reading logs. I like your idea a lot and would love for you to share your stems with me. I, too, try to help my students love reading as much as I do (it MUST be a teacher thing!) The in-class reading was almost always a productive time- and certainly the quietest time of the day! Right now, I am working on integrating more reading and writing into math instruction- and every other subject my kids take- we’re SPED- we do it all :)As always, I love hearing from you, Elona!

  3. Emmanuel Anama on June 28th, 2012 11:44 am

    I am so pleased to read about your research and supported documentation into the field of reading, and how to have students “talk” to the text that they are reading.

    Your professional experiences are fantastic, and I would like to try some of the ideas which you presented. I am a fellow in the 2012 Mountain Writing Project in Hazard, Kentucky, and we are constantly looking for ways to improve our teaching strategies.

    Thanks again for your help!
    Emmanuel 🙂

  4. Lori Inostroz on July 10th, 2012 10:01 am

    I’d love to have a copy of your sentence stems. I know this will help all my second grade readers, especially my ELLs. I’ve always hated book reports and reading logs. This seems as a more natural way to respond to literature. Thanks for the great idea!
    Lori Inostroz´s last blog post ..Learning styles explained simply to assist students in completing their learning plans

  5. Annabelle Warner on August 7th, 2012 4:58 pm

    Hi!! I’ve enjoyed reading your blogs & getting positive ideas!!! Please send me your sentence stems & format. Thanks!!

  6. Candice Young on August 8th, 2012 11:32 am

    I am an adult learner and LPC graduate student who loves to read.I try my best to be an example,especially to the young people in my life. This sounds interesting and engaging,can you send me a copy of your sentence stems & format please. This is my first time on the site, but certainly won’t be my last.
    Thanks so much!

  7. Helen Giannakoulis on August 17th, 2012 3:58 pm

    This is a great idea! I would love to see your sentence stems and format. Not only does this foster honesty about their reading, but it fosters comprehension skills. Awesome.

  8. Tiffany on September 3rd, 2012 10:11 pm

    Thanks for sharing! I would love to see a copy of the sentence stems and reading log that you use! Thanks in advance.

  9. Kathy Wood on October 22nd, 2012 2:31 pm

    I would love to have a copy of the question stems and project ideas.

  10. Lisa on October 24th, 2012 4:05 pm

    I would also love a copy!

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

 Subscribe to stay up to date. Teachers at Risk is informative. It's free.

  • apple144
  • Meta

  • Archives